Why Do We Keep Having the Same Arguments? How Couples Relationship Therapy Can Help

“We have had this conversation a hundred times.”

If that sounds familiar, you are certainly not alone.

Many couples find themselves having the same argument repeatedly. It might be about money, sex, housework, children, family, time together, socialising or something that happened years ago. Yet underneath the different subjects, the argument often follows exactly the same pattern.

One partner raises an issue. The other becomes defensive or withdraws. The first partner becomes more frustrated and pushes harder. The second partner shuts down further. Eventually, both feel unheard, angry and exhausted.

The argument ends, but the underlying problem remains.

Then, a few days or weeks later, it happens all over again.

This is one of the most common reasons couples seek couples relationship therapy.

Why do couples keep having the same arguments?

It can be tempting to think that couples repeatedly argue because one or both partners are unwilling to compromise.

Sometimes that is part of the problem. But often, the real issue is more complicated.

The argument you are having may not actually be about the subject you think it is about.

A disagreement about the washing-up, for example, might actually be about feeling unappreciated.

An argument about spending money might be about security and trust.

A disagreement about sex might be about rejection, loneliness, pressure or feeling undesirable.

An argument about seeing friends or family might be about feeling prioritised — or not prioritised — within the relationship.

Over time, couples can develop predictable patterns of interaction. Each person’s response triggers the other person’s response, creating a cycle that becomes increasingly difficult to break.

The problem may be the pattern, rather than either person

Imagine a couple where one partner regularly complains that the other never talks about their feelings.

The more they pursue a conversation, the more the other partner feels criticised and overwhelmed. They withdraw or become defensive.

The withdrawal then confirms the first partner’s belief that they don’t care, so they pursue even more strongly.

The more one partner pursues, the more the other withdraws.

Eventually both feel justified:

“You never listen to me.”

“I can’t say anything without you attacking me.”

Neither person necessarily intends to hurt the other. Yet the pattern itself keeps creating hurt.

This is sometimes described as a pursue-withdraw cycle.

There are many variations. Some couples become locked into criticism and defensiveness. Others alternate between anger and silence. Some avoid difficult subjects altogether until resentment eventually explodes.

The important thing is that the cycle can become more powerful than either individual.

Why communication advice doesn’t always work

You may already have tried talking about your communication.

Perhaps you have agreed to:

  • Listen more carefully
  • Stop interrupting
  • Stay calm
  • Have regular conversations
  • Avoid bringing up the past
  • Take time out when arguments become heated
  • Use “I” statements

All of these can be useful.

But if you are already caught in a deeply established relationship pattern, knowing what you should do is not always enough to change it.

When emotions become intense, people can revert to familiar ways of protecting themselves.

One person may attack because they are frightened of being ignored.

Another may withdraw because they feel overwhelmed or afraid that anything they say will make things worse.

The behaviour can look unreasonable from the outside, but it often makes sense when you understand what is happening emotionally underneath it.

This is where couples therapy can be particularly helpful.

How couples relationship therapy can help

Couples therapy provides a structured, confidential space to slow the pattern down and understand what is happening between you.

Rather than simply deciding who is right or wrong, therapy looks at the relationship as a whole.

We can explore questions such as:

  • What tends to trigger your arguments?
  • What happens immediately before things escalate?
  • What does each of you do when you feel hurt or threatened?
  • What are you each trying to communicate?
  • What happens when one partner becomes angry?
  • What happens when one partner withdraws?
  • What needs are not being expressed?
  • Are there underlying fears about rejection, abandonment, criticism or loss?
  • How do previous experiences influence the way you respond to each other?
  • What would you both like to be different?

The aim is to help you recognise the cycle while you are in it, rather than only afterwards.

Learning to understand each other’s perspective

When couples are stuck in conflict, it is easy to become focused on proving your own point.

You may know exactly what your partner is doing wrong.

Your partner probably feels equally certain about what you are doing wrong.

Therapy can help create enough space for both perspectives to be heard.

This does not mean agreeing with everything your partner says.

It means developing a greater understanding of what is happening for both of you.

For example, underneath:

“You never make time for me.”

there may be:

“I don’t feel important to you anymore.”

And underneath:

“You’re always demanding more from me.”

there may be:

“I feel as though I can never get it right.”

When these underlying feelings can be expressed safely, couples sometimes find that the argument begins to change.

What about anger?

Anger is often one of the most visible parts of relationship conflict, but it is not necessarily the underlying emotion.

Anger can develop when someone feels hurt, frightened, rejected, powerless or unheard.

This does not mean that anger should be excused, particularly where there is intimidation, coercion or abuse.

Rather, understanding what is underneath anger can help couples develop healthier ways of expressing difficult emotions.

Where there are concerns about domestic abuse, coercive control or safety, couples therapy may not be appropriate and a different form of specialist support may be required.

What happens in couples therapy?

During an initial couples therapy session, I will usually invite both partners to talk about what has brought them to therapy and what they would each like to change.

We will explore the history of your relationship, the difficulties you are experiencing and the patterns that have developed between you.

You do not need to arrive knowing exactly what is wrong.

Many couples come to therapy knowing only that they are unhappy, disconnected or stuck.

Part of the therapeutic process is working together to understand why.

Depending on your circumstances, therapy may draw on approaches including Gottman Method Couples Therapy, psychodynamic therapy, CBT, attachment-based approaches and trauma-informed therapy.

The work is tailored to the individual couple rather than following a rigid formula.

Couples therapy is not about taking sides

One of the concerns people sometimes have about relationship counselling is that the therapist will decide who is right.

That isn’t the purpose of couples therapy.

My role is to help both partners understand themselves, each other and the relationship patterns that are causing difficulty.

There may be behaviours that need to change. There may be unresolved hurts that need to be addressed. There may be individual issues affecting the relationship.

But the focus is on creating a better understanding of what is happening and helping you find more constructive ways of relating.

When should you consider couples therapy?

You don’t have to wait until your relationship is on the verge of ending.

Couples often seek therapy when:

  • The same arguments keep happening
  • Communication has deteriorated
  • You feel emotionally disconnected
  • You have stopped enjoying being together
  • One or both of you feel unheard or misunderstood
  • Arguments are becoming increasingly intense
  • You are struggling with intimacy or sex
  • Trust has been damaged
  • There has been an affair
  • You are considering separation
  • You feel more like housemates than partners
  • You have tried to resolve things yourselves without success

Seeking help isn’t necessarily a sign that your relationship has failed.

Sometimes it is a recognition that the relationship matters enough to work on.

What if we can’t even agree about what the problem is?

This is very common.

One partner may believe the relationship has a communication problem. The other may think the real issue is sex. One may want to repair the relationship while the other is questioning whether they want to remain together.

You do not have to agree about everything before starting therapy.

The first step can simply be creating a space where both perspectives can be explored.

From there, it may become clearer what needs to change and whether you can work towards that together.

Breaking the cycle

Recurring arguments can leave couples feeling hopeless.

You may start to believe that your partner will never change, or that you will always have the same argument.

But relationship patterns are learned, and learned patterns can change.

The goal isn’t necessarily to create a relationship where you never disagree. Healthy couples can have very different opinions and still have a strong relationship.

The goal is to develop ways of dealing with differences that do not repeatedly leave one or both partners feeling hurt, rejected, angry or alone.

Sometimes the most important question isn’t:

“How do we stop arguing?”

but:

“What happens between us when we disagree, and how can we change that pattern?”

That is often where meaningful change begins.

Couples Relationship Therapy in Dalston Hackney London and Online

I am an accredited Psychosexual and Relationship Psychotherapist and Couples Therapist, with more than 25 years’ experience working with individuals and couples.

I work with couples experiencing communication difficulties, recurring conflict, emotional disconnection, affairs, loss of trust, intimacy and sexual difficulties, separation and relationship breakdown.

My approach is integrative, attachment-based and trauma-informed, drawing on approaches including Gottman Method Couples Therapy, Imago, psychodynamic therapy and CBT.

Couples relationship therapy is available from my therapy space in Hackney, North East London (N16), as well as online via Zoom for couples in the UK and internationally.

Thinking about couples therapy?

If you keep having the same argument and are struggling to find a way forward, you don’t have to work it out alone.

Contact me to arrange an initial consultation and discuss what is happening in your relationship and how couples therapy could help.

Contact Rosalind Simpson rosalind@citydynamictherapy.co.uk or Tel 07948 872 907

Find out more about Couples & Relationship Therapy

Share: